Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Game of Thrones: "The Lion and the Rose" Review

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Game of Thrones: "The Lion and the Rose" Review



    Warning: Full spoilers for the episode follow...














    Now that's how you end a wedding.

    Hahaha. So long, dick face!

    Sure, it might have been more gratifying to see King Joffrey meet his end at the actual hands of someone who hated him, with him seeing the face of his attacker and knowing why he was being killed - like with Arya and Polliver back in the season premiere. But there's also something to be said for spending a full minute in agony, choking to death in front of hundreds of people, eyes bulging and blood oozing from your nose. I'll take that over a quicker death via dagger or sword any day.

    And while George R. R. Martin still insists on ending each wedding we see with a gruesome death (or twelve), he's willing to make some concessions. As it turns out, the person we hated the most on this series was also on the murder menu. And for this brief moment, Martin comes off as an equal opportunity smiter. It's also worth mentioning that Martin himself wrote this particular episode - "The Lion and the Rose" - and in doing so got to bring Joffrey's death to life - as close as he could to how he once envisioned it in A Storm of Swords. I'll bring up Martin a bit later on in the review, but this episode was the great example of a source author being brought in to, all at once, replicate, rework, and re-envision their original story.

    But let's dive into the wedding here. Because for those of you who didn't read the books and didn't know Joffrey was going to die, I feel like you must have known something was going to happen. Because those final minutes featuring Joffrey pouring wine on Tyrion's head, and then humiliating him by making him cupbearer (a shitbird to the very end!), were definitely leading toward a big moment. It just might not have been clear what that moment was going to be. Was Tyrion going to snap? Someone had to. Though Tyrion also probably hadn't had enough wine to truly lose his senses. But the episode had definitely done its work and showed us how Joffrey was literally surrounded by dozens of people, from different houses all over Westeros, who hated his guts.


    "I now pronounce you King and Queen A-Hole."

    In fact, everyone seemed to be in a foul mood in general, as we saw several character interactions at the reception that ranged from passive aggressive (Oberyn with Tywin and Cersei) to bitter (Jaime and Loras) to openly hostile (Cersei with Pycelle). Cersei seemed to be the the eye of the storm here, getting more and more annoyed with everyone as she came to terms with no longer being Queen. She even decided to bust Brienne's chops over Jaime - a man she no longer even seems to be interested in herself. It's worth noting too that the series has landed down firmly on the "Brienne secretly loves Jaime" side of the fence, which weakens her character if you ask me.

    And in the midst of all this "revelry," was Joffrey - drawing everyone's ire with a foolish display of little people reenacting the War of the Five Kings. I did like how Olenna cried out for someone to help Joffrey when he was choking though. Because she knew what side her bread was buttered on. Minutes earlier, she'd been one of the folks taking offense to the dwarf display and now she was worried about Margaery's standing.

    We can all wonder whether or not Joffrey was poisoned (mayhaps he choked on his own douche juices), though Dontos spiriting away with Sansa surely suggests foul play. And while it looks like Tyrion's about to be done up with extreme counts of treason and regicide, any good defense attorney could clearly state that Joffrey made Tyrion pour him wine from his own table. This being Westeros and all though, I'm sure "reasonable doubt" won't enter the picture.

    http://www.ign.com/videos/2014/02/25...-family-teaser

    Earlier on in the episode, the seeds were planted once again for a Joffrey/Tyrion showdown. Tyrion had gifted Joffrey with a book called The Lives of Four Kings and then Joffrey swiftly destroyed it with his new sword of Valyrian steel. For a moment though, Joffrey looked as though he might be willing to play nice in public, giving Tyrion a decent "thank you" speech for the book. But hell, I'm sure an entire feature could be written about all the times that little monster fooled us into thinking that he possibly maybe could have matured out of his jerkwad stage, only to immediately do something ultra-despicable right afterwards.

    Also, still sticking with King's Landing before I head off to Dragonstone and the Dreadfort, Tyrion had to give Shae the boot for her own safety. Shae, who not only can't take a hint but also doesn't realize when someone's acting like they don't care. Again, Shae's scenes are so frustrating as she's stubborn to the point of not being able to pick up on any subtleties or subtext. Keep in mind, the way Tyrion banished her is the exact same way John Lithgow had to make Bigfoot run for his life back in 1987's Harry and the Hendersons. So if anyone wants to split hairs about why this episode didn't get a "10," I don't mind. But look no further than this scene. "I can't be in love with a whore!"

    We caught up with Bran very briefly here. Enough to see him touch a "heart tree" and flash through a bunch of images which apparently gave him valuable insight. Even more interesting though were the goings on over at The Dreadfort -- Lord Bolton's hold -- which we got to see for the first time. And here was a case where Martin got to circle back and drum up some scenes that we never experienced in the books. Just like the Theon torture scenes from last season.

    The Bolton stuff is a little trickier though since so many things have happened off screen and have only been spoken of that some of it may have swerved around some viewers brains. Like when Bolton mentioned to Ramsay that Moat Cailin, which essentially bottlenecks the North and the Riverlands, is being held by the Ironborn. We've never seen Moat Cailin on the show, nor has it ever been mentioned before. It's also probably a surprise that the Ironborn are still tinkering around in The North.

    I'm guessing that it helped more than a few people out just to directly show us that Ramsay was Lord Bolton's bastard son. It was mentioned, complete with a cut between Bolton talking to Walder Frey and Ramsay, in the Season 3 finale, but seeing the two of them together still feels long overdue. There's a bunch of information here that I won't sift through (Locke's headed to The Wall to kill Bran, Rickon and Jon Snow, Ramsay's taking Theon to Moat Cailin to try and trade him for the land), but the absolute core of it all involved Theon now being Ramsay's chew toy. An obedient lap dog who officially goes by "Reek." A man so beaten and traumatized that not only does he barely flinch when Ramsay mentions Robb's death, but he also doesn't bare to nick Ramsay's face much less slit his throat while shaving him with a straight razor.

    And of course Ramsay and Locke are best buds. Sadistic freaks stick together, right?

    Over in Stannis-land, things could be going better. The brooding Baratheon brother still has eyes for the throne (which will grow even wider when he discovers Joffrey's fate, I assume), but he barely has enough food to feed his family. All he can do to pass the time and keep the faith is burn "heretics" at the stake, which one can only imagine is a bitch for morale. Though it does seem a staunch "Lord of Light" devotion is growing out of everyone's fear. One (slightly) redeeming quality that Stannis still possesses is that he doesn't outright loathe his daughter like Selyse does. He does however send Melisandre (who must be having an awkward old time these days) down to Shireen's dank, prison-y quarters to convert her to their new religion. All in all, Stannis is running to a stand still.

    Odds and Ends:
    • Not only was it great to see Tyrion and Jaime have their first scene together after three years, but MORE JAIME AND BRONN NOW! I loved watching Jaime, a man everyone assumes has no honor, get paired up with a "Knight" who fights dishonorably. It's the new Arya/Syrio "dancing" lessons. I know the episode ended with a giant event that could shake up the capital, but I certainly hope it doesn't stop this new duo.
    • "The dwarf, the cripple, and the mother of madness."
    • No Arya or Dany or Jon this week. Which is fine given the fact that freakin' Joffrey's dead (Huzzah!). But being two episodes in and not having Dany do anything important is giving me flashbacks to Season 2.
    • Ramsay's still keen on hunting people for sport, I see. And he had a girl named Miranda, equally disturbed, by his side. (note: not sure if this is an HBO rejiggering of Myranda Royce of The Vale from the books)
    • Ramsay told Lord Bolton that he sent an offer of trade to Balon, but left out the part about sending Theon's amputated dong along with the message.
    • Highgarden's Mace Tyrell (father of Margaery and Loras) made his debut. Though he was literally told to buzz off and shut up at one point in favor of an Olenna/Tywin scene. (note: Olenna made reference to the Iron Bank. I don't recall it being mentioned on the show before, but some folks in the comments are saying it was brought up briefly last season.)
    • That was Sigur Rós playing at the wedding by the way.


    The Verdict

    This outstanding episode of Thrones featured a shocking death that was actually an immense crowd-pleaser. Go figure. I'm sure it won't go down completely smooth as Tyrion will probably get framed for whatever it was that happened, but at least that rotten little beast of a king is gone for good. It wasn't a perfect episode as the bulk of its greatness took place during the final fifteen minutes, though some could argue that Joffrey's demise outweighs all. Also, we finally saw Lord Bolton and Ramsey together. And bearing witness to Theon as "Reek" was formidably jarring. At least the poor bastard's not getting sliced and diced anymore.
    The Hackmaster

  • #2
    There is a spoiler tag for these things.

    Spoiler Alert! Click to view...
    Super cool information some people might not want to know yet.


    Also, who wrote this article?
    Please put all complaints in writing and submit them here.

    Above link not working? Try here.

    Comment


    • #3
      I forgot to quote the source

      By Matt Fowler

      Where is the spoiler tag at? I don't see it, I've looked everywhere for it.
      Last edited by dlevere; 04-14-2014, 06:20:25 PM.
      The Hackmaster

      Comment


      • #4
        Because I created it myself, there's no button. Just use spoiler and ispoiler (inline spoiler) with square brackets.
        Spoiler Alert! Click to view...
        Stuff

        This is how you use an inline spoiler
        Please put all complaints in writing and submit them here.

        Above link not working? Try here.

        Comment


        • #5
          LOL, O.K., no wonder that I couldn't find it.
          The Hackmaster

          Comment


          • #6
            10 Most Shocking Game of Thrones Deaths

            By Matt Fowler

            This is the part where I warn those who aren't caught up on the show about massive spoilers for every inch of HBO's Game Of Thrones that has aired so far. The article's about GoT deaths! What are you even doing in here?











            Spoiler Alert! Click to view...
            [spoiler]So here we are, almost a week out from the Purple Wedding. Where King Joffrey once again made a huge spectacle of himself.

            Though, this time it was by violently gurgling to death in front of everyone at his wedding reception.

            [/url]

            Yet another shocking turn of events for a show that's re-written the book (even the ones it's based on) on shocking events. And so while we all lay back in the comfortable afterglow of King Douchey's demise, let's look back at some of the most shocking deaths from the past three seasons.

            And no, not every death is shocking. Bloody, painful deaths are pretty much the way of the world when it comes to Westeros. It takes a very special death to make us sit up in our seats and go "Whoa, they're not messing around!"

            http://www.ign.com/videos/2014/04/18...n-conversation

            Of course, sometimes we do more than just sit upright. Sometimes we shriek and holler like the world's coming to an quick end. Here are 10 Shocking Game of Thrones Deaths:

            King Joffrey Baratheon

            Yes, let's start off with the big death from last week's "The Lion and the Rose." The one that many considered to be a glorious gift from author George R. R. Martin - compensation for so many beloved characters getting snuffed out over the years. Proof that a shocking death didn't have to make us angry or sad. It could lift our spirits and give us a newfound faith in the material.


            Downblouse.

            So there was Joffrey, oozing his face off in front of hundreds of lords and lades from all over the realm. Sure, a "Who Poisoned the King?" mystery could be fun, but keep in mind that we were still never given a hard answer regarding who killed Jon Arryn back in Season 1. Yeah, remember that old puzzle?



            Mycah the Butcher's Boy

            Speaking of Season 1, and our long-standing hate for Joffrey, one of the ways Game of Thrones showed us it meant business was by almost immediately killing children and dogs. Soldiers? Whatever. Grown ass politicians? Who cares. The first episode ended with Bran almost dying, but in the second episode - "The Kingsroad" - we found out the hard way that it just didn't pay to stand up to bullies. And by that, I mean Arya standing up to bullies and then her lowborn friend Mycah paying the price for it.



            It feels so far off now, being all the way back in the second episode, but I think it's important to look back at this event given what a "fan favorite" The Hound's become as of late. And though Arya's at his side now, she still holds him accountable for this monstrous deed. Even if he was only following Joffrey's orders (*cough* without a peep of protest).

            Viserys Targaryen

            Season 1 was a strange time indeed as many were still trying go figure out what Daenerys' role in the overall series was. Hell, it took more than a few episodes for non-book readers to even connect the dots and figure out how her family figured into the past events in Westeros. And so, as much as we hated her older brother Viserys, we certainly weren't expecting anything to drastically change in her world.


            Fondue? Fondon't,

            Then Khal Drogo poured a bowl of molten gold on Viserys' head and we all gave the show a slow clap followed by an appropriate "not bad" facial expression. Not only had many considered Viserys' to be a major character who normally, by the rules of TV, would have been safe, but he was someone we hated and wanted to see die. By the way, only one of those traits would carry on throughout the show. No one was safe, that was true. But it would be a long ass time before we saw someone truly villainous get their just desserts. Like, say, choking on dry pigeon pie.

            Khal Drogo

            Let's stay with Dany's world a bit longer so that we can mourn the surprising passing of her "sun and stars," Khal Drogo. Another moment when the story tricked us into thinking we were watching a character who'd stick around for a long time. A character who'd never ever, say, succumb to a fluke infection brought about by a scrape. Of course, we later discovered that there was some Lhazareen mysticism involved, but it was still a rather ignoble way to meet defeat.


            This could be us but you playin!

            Making things worse, Dany made a blood pact with the witch to revive Drogo, and wound up having to smother him to death after she was left with nothing but a lobotomized lunk. Still, this was probably the most stable, loving relationship on all of Game of Thrones.

            Ser Rodrik Cassel

            No, Ser Rodrik wasn't a character who the fans clung to in any meaningful way, but his death was still a doozy as it essentially represented the "Fall of Winterfell" at the end of Season 2. Remember, most viewers were still laboring under the delusion of "well, nothing else could possibly happen to The Starks."



            Still, at least Rodrik got to go out like a badass. Basically giving as few "fucks" as possible while Theon tried to make him fall in line. Too bad his neck was so thick and Theon's chopping arm was so weak that it took several hacks to separate head from body.

            Sadly, there aren't many surprising deaths up at Castle Black and Beyond The Wall. Unless you count all deaths as surprising. Which you really shouldn't when you're dealing with a band of thieves, killers and rapists swearing an oath to protect the realm from psycho hill people and ice zombies. Because "death by dirty marauder and/or frozen, undead demon" is all part of the game.

            [/url]

            And much like Ser Rodrik, Commander Mormont (Jorah's dad for those who'd never made the connection) wasn't exactly anyone to dedicate a Tumblr blog to. But he did represent stability in Jon's crazy world. Much like Rodrik with Bran's world. So to see Mormont get gutted by his own mutinous underlings was not only shocking, but it left us all with a morbid "What the frak's the Night Watch going to do now?" feeling.

            Renly Baratheon

            In which the War of the Five Kings quickly become the Scuffle of the Four Guys.

            Oh, Renly. You can fill your camp with soldiers and surround your tent with guards, but absolutely nothing can protect you from a sinister shadowy vapor version of your brother Stannis stabbing you in the back with a blade made of black mist.


            "Delete...my...browser history."

            And we had just barely gotten over the shock of seeing Melisandre giving birth to this unholy cloud of demon residue. And there it was, within a few scenes of the next episode, hissing its way into Renly's inner circle and gas-sassinating him in front of Catelyn and Brienne. Fratricide at its most foul and foggy.

            Eddard "Ned" Stark

            Remember how everyone's jaw dropped back when Ned was beheaded in Season 1? Seems so run of the mill now.


            "I hope someone avenges me. Literally anyone. I'll take whatever."

            How young and innocent we all were back then. It was cute how much we thought that Sean Bean's Ned was going to be the main character on the series. And that he'd get to the bottom of the Jon Arryn murder mystery and triumph as a hero. Adorable. Ooh, I could just pinch our collective cheeks.

            It's funny how often the show chooses to teach us that no one is safe, only for us to almost immediately forget the lesson a few episodes later. But yeah, Ned's big spectacle of a death at the end of the episode "Baelor" was basically the defining moment for the series - whether you're talking about the books or the show. It also tricked many people into thinking that Robb Stark was destined to be the hero of the story. HAHAHAHA THIS IS FUN!

            Talisa Stark (née Maegyr)

            Okay, so I'm separating Talisa's heinous death out from the rest of the Red Wedding carnage. I know. It's weird. But not only was she the first to get taken out, but the sight of seeing a pregnant woman stabbed right in the stomach was next-level disturbing. Still the hardest death to watch out of all the mayhem in "The Rains of Castamere" if you ask me.


            Talisa's reaction to her own death in the Red Wedding. Posted on YouTube.

            Plus, the character of "Robb's wife" (she was an all together different person in the books) wasn't even at the Red Wedding in the novel A Storm of Swords. So the show could have done the same here. It could have left her out of the picture. But producers/writers D.B. Weiss and David Benioff chose to include her in the mass mutilation. Oh, and make her "with child." Yes, if there was a "salt in gaping wound" moment for the book readers, it was this one.

            Robb Stark, Catelyn Stark, and a Shitload More

            And then there's the rest. Robb, Catelyn, Greywind, many a drunken Stark bannerman. All done in at the cruel hands of Walder Frey and Roose Bolton.


            How'd I do?

            The trauma inflicted on unsuspecting viewers by the Red Wedding is now etched in history. With so much notoriety that the term's now become an easy reference point for "the worst thing you've ever seen." It can also be used as a verb and an adjective for any and all occasions when something goes horribly wrong in your life. Funny how we so quickly we shrug off moments of sadness and despair by deflecting our feelings with humor. Now, if you'll excuse me. I have to think up a funny caption to put under the picture of Roose Bolton murdering Robb Stark.[/ispoiler]
            Last edited by dlevere; 04-19-2014, 01:02:30 PM. Reason: Can't get spoiler tag to work
            The Hackmaster

            Comment

            Working...
            X